When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
7 comments
Newest
OldestMost Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
PyroSamurai
1 year ago
Why did the hypnosis wear off? Hypnosis is set and forget, not maintain.
Always Expect The Worst
1 year ago
… why is the “catnip” a huge stick?
Catnip is a thin and spindly annual, and the part used to attract cats is the leaves and the flowerbuds, not the stems…. and the stems are never thick enough to be sticks…. it dies back every winter….
Why is it a huge stick??
This is bothering me more than it should.
The Demonic crusader
2 years ago
Tbh I think your review is my personal opinion too but I will still read it since its the only manga that’s even a bit close to the world of otome game is tough for mobs well of you have any manga similar to that please recommend me.
RedDragonLord
3 years ago
Damnit Cat sensei. You fucking muffinhead!
So, I finally finished all available chapters. Whew. What a pain. I have a lot to point out about the mess of events and things but fuck it.
I rate it 4.5/10 It’s below average. I was gonna give it a 3 but 1.5 extra points for Eliza. She’s best girl in this manga. Even better than that bubbly protagonist who doesn’t act like one at all.
Also, the MC is lame af. At the beginning I thought this will be like World of otome games is tough for mobs but ofcourse this doesn’t even come close to ite shadows.
Also, who the hell came up with that title?! Normally titles tell the summary or nature of these manga but the blacksmith part is just one of the side features of MC.
This manga starts interesting looking things, like that book of magic MC learns from or even blacksmithing which I thought will become akin to a cheat like ability but nah, they all just got lost in the shadows soon after and we get these bland and painfully obvious events with no interesting design to capture the reader’s attention. The characters at the beginning seemed interesting but now they have stopped being that.
I don’t usually complain like this but I made the mistake of expecting something out of this manga and was disappointed so let me just blurt out my frustration. Don’t mind my ramblings too much. They are at the end personal opinions.
Why did the hypnosis wear off? Hypnosis is set and forget, not maintain.
… why is the “catnip” a huge stick?
Catnip is a thin and spindly annual, and the part used to attract cats is the leaves and the flowerbuds, not the stems…. and the stems are never thick enough to be sticks…. it dies back every winter….
Why is it a huge stick??
This is bothering me more than it should.
Tbh I think your review is my personal opinion too but I will still read it since its the only manga that’s even a bit close to the world of otome game is tough for mobs well of you have any manga similar to that please recommend me.
Damnit Cat sensei. You fucking muffinhead!
So, I finally finished all available chapters. Whew. What a pain. I have a lot to point out about the mess of events and things but fuck it.
I rate it 4.5/10 It’s below average. I was gonna give it a 3 but 1.5 extra points for Eliza. She’s best girl in this manga. Even better than that bubbly protagonist who doesn’t act like one at all.
Also, the MC is lame af. At the beginning I thought this will be like World of otome games is tough for mobs but ofcourse this doesn’t even come close to ite shadows.
Also, who the hell came up with that title?! Normally titles tell the summary or nature of these manga but the blacksmith part is just one of the side features of MC.
This manga starts interesting looking things, like that book of magic MC learns from or even blacksmithing which I thought will become akin to a cheat like ability but nah, they all just got lost in the shadows soon after and we get these bland and painfully obvious events with no interesting design to capture the reader’s attention. The characters at the beginning seemed interesting but now they have stopped being that.
I don’t usually complain like this but I made the mistake of expecting something out of this manga and was disappointed so let me just blurt out my frustration. Don’t mind my ramblings too much. They are at the end personal opinions.