Rating
Skeleton Soldier Couldn’T Protect The Dungeon Average 4.7 / 5 out of 611
Rank
13th, it has 112.3K monthly views
Alternative
Skeleton Soldier ; Skeleton Soldier (Skeleton Soldier Couldn't Protect the Dungeon) ; 해골병사는 던전을 지키지 못했다, The Skeleton Soldier Failed to Defend the Dungeon
Author(s)
Artist(s)
Type
Manhwa
Is it good?
Story has kinda fallen off ch 273. If I had to pick a point I’d say it was
It’s not like it’s in the gutter but it’s headed down hill.
there seems to be a loading problem whit the last 3 chapters
isaac my beloved
where is the novel to this manhwa? I want to read the source if it is translated
It’s a long story, and so far after 140 chapters i am enjoying it a lot.
It’s a story about regret and learning from your mistakes. Your life may not regress but boy are there patterns that repeat. Once you understand this you can stop making the same mistakes.
Fire
Its a really great story except for the hell arc .It does jumps which seem like missing chapters and its getting concluded but looking back nothing made sense.But thats only one arc and after chap 200 .I also dont have a problem with capter 200 it does make sense and is no plothole .I definetly recommend reading this
Man the haters are pathetic….. it hasn’t violated its own rules and is slowly pushing the envelope of the world. Some people have no patience to sit down and understand what they are reading…
Ahh I still see the lore implications that occurred after chapter 200 have still not been addressed, probably Never will to all future readers don’t get invested in the lore, it shall be wiped each time whenever the studio or author finds convenient.
A manga that can not follow its own rules and can change the entirety of its lore on the drop of a dime and does so even once will most likely in the future do it on multiple occasions just to extend itself, a story like that will never be worth the read, die hards will downvote this comment but to them I ask can you try to justify what just happened on chapter 200 everything we learned from chapter 1-200 was invalidated in an instant, I was heavily invested in the lore then they have the gm thanos snap everything we learned was true out of existence along with all the mc’s skills and levels, everything he worked for can and will be instantly taken away, I and all the readers have every right to be mad, you can’t just do that without people saying yeah no we know where this is going and see some of your fanbase stop caring about your book.
Ps: I am 100% sure some jack *** is gonna downvote me so I want you to know in advance whoever you are the moment they do a wipe again imma be here to make fun of it, deep down you all know the author is not gonna be able to resist doing it again and when it happens imma be back here to warn others.
And with that I rest my case see ya next time in the comments section when they do it again.
So the point of this story is that the skele gets better each time to protect the folks he builds up with. These folks don’t know that and it kind of builds this nobility around the skele. This is then subverted when folks start “remembering” their past lives.
None of that would matter though if the story didn’t degrade into a “what’s in the box” kind of telling. You’ll find loads of mysteries early on like who is Kevin Ashton. But that’s kind of like the Will of D in one piece it’s fine cause you know that it’s end game and in the background, you’re here for the world building and characters. But the world building starts becoming “whats in the box”, so chapter by chapter it’s what’s in this room? What’s behind that door? Etc..
That’s just stupid.
SPOILERS:
The story violated its own lore. You find out that even though the MC regressed that the other characters would start dreaming and flashes of their previous relationships with him. We were getting closer to solving the mystery of how the MCgets to his first master and what her motivation was in lying to a lowly skeleton soldier. And ep 200 destroyed all of it. We have no idea if the first person he saw in the new timeline even exists (and he seems to have no interest in investigating) nor do we know if any of the rules from before the hard reset apply. It flushed 199 eps of great, tight storytelling down the drain, including the MC’s curiosity.
199 breathtaking chapters. On the 200th, it got so bad so fast it was shocking. But with 199 amazing issues to look back at, it’s still one of my favorite stories ever told. The last 3 arcs have been horrific. I want to believe the author died and this is their talentless kid writing instead bc it makes no sense otherwise.
Was it dropped?
24th Official Manhwa Review
This one is a ride….
Plot, complicated 7/10
Uniqueness, 8/10
Onion cutting ninja, I cant get a single break from this man
Character Devlopment, very very slow and still working on it so 6/10
Plot Development, The Change after ch.200 makes things werid so yes and no 7/10
Side characters 9.8/10
Romance, ?????Maybe in the future???/ but not right now
Art style, starts out a little rough and gets much better 8/10
Fit tags? Yes
Violence, Yeah
Comedy, here and there
MC, 6/10…..he dumb…..and character development feels extremely drawn out I don’t want OP and perfect off the bat, but this is DRAWN out
Action, 7/10
Villians, Hateable
Plot armor, I can’t rank this because you could say none or alot so I say *silence*
memorability 8/10
Regression, A WHOLE lot of that
Menace to society? no
Anti-Hero? not really
Borderline Villian? also not really
Hero, also not really
Revenge plot, Yup
Waifus, we have QUALITY around here, but no romance yet or ever possibly so big SAD
Character art style 8/10
Background Art Style 8.6/10
Translation, mostly pretty good can get rough on a few chapters
Mistakes, a few here and there
How dark is this? bro this Is DARKK like If he wasn’t a skeleton nah fam
Final Ranking 7.6/10
Bookmarked, Yes
Should you read? Up to you
Manhwa Review Rules
Must have 50+ Chapters
Must be above 4.0 Stars
Unofficial Reviews are Personal opinions
All Reviews must be as unbiased as possible
Must be honest with Review
Re-Reviewing is possible after 50+ more chapters and enough people wanting me to change my review
The Next Manhwa to be reviewed will be……………God Game
Cya in the next one folks 