The Tanaka Family Reincarnates

Generally okay is currently a 7/10 but could be a 8-9/10 IF it didnt have one amazingly large and glaring issue…

This story gives too much focus and leans in to Emma (basically the mc at this point). It’s supposed to be the “Tanaka Family Reincarnates” not this “Reincarnated life of Emma and the Rest of her family” bs. The author is working this off as supposed to be a multi-character driven narrative but it revolves all around Emma and runs the gears down quite a bit even to the point that it’s obviously stated in the material itself but does nothing to properly address the issue. Cool give her characteristics, STOP IGNORING THE REST OF THE MAIN CAST. The way this has been set up is to basically make one of the female mc’s the one and only selling point while the rest is just background characters with nothing really fleshed out and basically just joke characters with their “other life experience” being put to use like once or twice tops. At this point you could literally interchange some of the side characters or even one of the brothers and/or parents and I wouldnt notice the difference half the time, that’s how flat the rest of the characters feel.
It’s the same basic “romance” you’d see in any fantasy, daily life, school, or isekai story.

This manga’s going to go downhill quick if Emma doesnt get a narrative cold shoulder for a bit and the rest of the main cast gets more love and attention given to them. If it continues how it’s currently going then it’ll just spiral into this weird character-specific fetish plot about how everyone loves this one specific character for whatever bs reason.

The one(.5) reason(s) I keep getting drawn back into it is because the person making this story has definitely put in at least more than the modicum of thought into the greater worldbuilding of the story unlike other people who make isekai trash ripoffs. Unfortunately the writing goes halfway down the drain with the amount of tropes Choko relies on is a bit uncanny and could use a bit of work. Bait n switch is so tackily common and the “everyone loves x character because they all make severe misconceptions” is also yuck.

[Review after release of Chapter 38]